Gluten Free Quick and Easy: recipe test

I wrote yesterday about my first impressions of Carol Fenster’s new book, Gluten Free Quick and Easy – and you can read my interview with Carol here. Today, I’m going to tell you about the recipes I’ve tried …

First batch: Chocolate Chip Cookies

I set out to make Double Chocolate Chip Cookies first – wouldn’t everyone – and I have to confess that they were a complete disaster. Husband rudely described them as moonrock … but it wasn’t Carol’s fault.

I do have a dim memory of my mother possessing two different sets of cup measures – one for UK measures, and one she’d acquired while living in the US. I only possess one set, and these were, of course, the wrong ones. As I set to, mixing and measuring for my choc chip cookies, this faint trace of memory did surface briefly, but didn’t make enough impact to change my process.

As no doubt you all know, a US cup is 8 fluid ounces; in the UK, it is 10 fluid ounces. As I tried to make the mix bind together to form a dough, I did think it was rather dry – no wonder, since I was using significantly more dry ingredients than Carol’s recipe called for, and my poor, lone egg didn’t have a chance. As a rule, here in the UK, we don’t use cup measures for baking, but pounds and ounces, so I was setting off at a disadvantage anyway.

Still, I think if I mix the moonrock with icecream, it will make very nice choc chip cookie icecream. See, I’m following Carol’s system of re-use already.

Once I’d done my research on the net, and found that the only US cup measures available on line here in the UK are out of stock (now, why would that be? Gap in the market here, folks), I decided to do complicated sums in my head, and convert cup measures to ounces …

baking cup measuresSecond batch: Scones

Now these turned out really rather well. None of the ‘gritty’ taste that often comes with gluten free products … I’ve eaten three already.

Carol’s baking process isn’t one I’m used to – her recipes all seem to start with blending the egg and fat, while I would usually rub the fat into the flour first – but it does work, and I was very pleased with the scones.

Third batch: Plain cookies/Raisin cookies

I’m beginning to crack the conversion technique, and these were a whole lot better than my first attempt! The ingredients pulled together to form a lovely workable dough.

Still perhaps slightly on the dry side – I’m cooking in an Aga, which brings its own unique style to every dish. Next time I’ll put the cookies higher up, and remove the cooling sheet part way through to let them brown.

I’m enjoying this review process – but I bet Carol never expected her recipes to be tested using UK measures on an antique Aga!

gooseberriesFourth batch: Gooseberry Cobbler

This was fabulous. I used gooseberries because we’ve a lot of those in the garden at the moment – and it was gorgeous. The topping is much lighter than a crumble topping, and went very well indeed with the gooseberries. I shall be producing this again at the weekend, when I have family coming.

All in all, I’d say that these recipes worked well, once I’d got over the initial cultural differences! I’d be happy to recommend this book, especially if you were based in America. And I think it would be particularly useful for someone new to the diet, because of the information surrounding the recipes.

For those of you not familiar with the conversion of US measures to UK measures, this might help:

1 cup = 0.5 pint. In US, 1 pint = 16 fluid ounces. In UK, 1 pint = 20 fluid ounces.

butter: 1 UK pound = 2 US cups
flour: 1 UK pound = 4 US cups
syrup: 12 UK ounces = 1 US cup
sugar: 1 UK pound = 2 US cups
milk/water: 0.5 UK pound (or 8 fl.oz) = 1 US cup

The differences are due to the different densities of the stuff to be measured.

I’m still working in imperial measures – if you’ve gone metric, you’ve got a different calculation to do

Published by


Lucy is the mother of a coeliac, and has been managing a gluten free diet for her daughter for 20 years - though, to be fair, she does do most of it herself now...

4 thoughts on “Gluten Free Quick and Easy: recipe test”

  1. Hmm finding myself on your blog a bit lately. If your looking for US cups, and you don’t find any, I’d be willing to send you some. Of course is always a good place to buy them too, you’d just have figure out how much your spending because you’d be buying from their US site.

    I haven’t gotten Carol’s book yet, maybe this is a good week to try that.

    P.S. No, so far, my daughter can eat whatever she wants. I do carry the gene, so I’ll be having her blood tested at her next physical. Since she is asymptomatic, I’m not going to have a special blood draw done for it. She’s 11 and terrified of needles.

  2. Laney, that’s a really kind offer – thank you. My 11 year old hates needles too …

    Calvin – we’ve got gooseberries because they are a local tradition. The village we live in has an annual gooseberry fair, where people’s prize berries are weighed to find out which are the heaviest. I’ve never been brave enough to enter, as we’d be laughed out of the marquee – the experts grow huge berries!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *